Both put you in the racing crouch, both look right on a cafe racer, and only one of them lets you arrive somewhere able to use your hands.
The actual difference
Clip-ons are two separate handlebar stubs that clamp directly around the fork tubes, usually below the top yoke. Clubmans are a single one-piece bar that bolts into your standard bar mounts and sweeps down and back.
That mounting difference is everything. Clip-ons sit lower, further forward and wider apart. Clubmans sit at the height of your standard bars but angled down, which is a much gentler change to your riding position than the photographs suggest.
Where the pain comes from
Not the angle. The weight distribution.
With clip-ons below the yoke you are supporting a meaningful fraction of your upper body through your wrists. At speed, airflow takes that load off you and everything feels wonderful. In traffic, at 40km/h, there is no airflow and your wrists are carrying you. That is why cafe racers feel superb on an open road and awful in a city.
At speed the wind carries you. At 40km/h in traffic your wrists carry you. That is the whole story.
The compromise nobody mentions
Clip-ons mounted above the top yoke, or on risers. A 40mm riser puts the bars roughly at clubman height while keeping the separated clip-on look and the narrower width.
This is what we fit on anything that gets ridden properly. It looks almost identical in photographs and the difference after an hour in the saddle is enormous.
Fitting
Clubmans are a twenty-minute job with no surprises. They use the existing mounts, and usually the existing cables reach.
Clip-ons are an afternoon. You will need to check fork tube diameter precisely, confirm the bars clear the tank at full lock, and most likely shorten or replace at least one cable. Budget for a longer front brake line as well.
What neither will fix
A seat mounted too far forward. If your riding position is cramped, changing the bars moves your hands but not your hips, and a cramped rider on clip-ons is worse than a cramped rider on standard bars.
Sort the seat position first, then choose the bars.
Clip-ons vs clubmans
| Mounting | Clip-ons clamp around the fork tubes | Clip-on |
|---|---|---|
| Mounting | Clubmans bolt to standard bar mounts | Clubman |
| Fitting time | Clubmans, using existing cables | 20 min |
| Fitting time | Clip-ons, with cable and line changes | Half a day |
| Wrist load | Clip-ons below the yoke, in traffic | High |
| Wrist load | Clubmans, or clip-ons on 40mm risers | Moderate |
| Best compromise | Clip-ons above the yoke on risers | 40 mm |
Common questions
What is the difference between clip-ons and clubman bars?
Clip-ons are two separate stubs that clamp around the fork tubes, usually below the top yoke. Clubmans are one piece that bolts into the standard bar mounts and sweeps down and back, sitting considerably higher.
Are clip-on handlebars uncomfortable?
Below the top yoke, yes, in town. They transfer your upper body weight through your wrists, and at low speed there is no airflow to take that load off you. On an open road at speed they feel excellent.
What is the most comfortable cafe racer handlebar?
Clubmans, or clip-ons mounted above the top yoke on around 40mm risers. The riser option keeps the separated clip-on appearance while putting the bars at roughly clubman height.
Do you need new cables when fitting clip-ons?
Usually at least one. Expect to shorten or replace throttle and clutch cables and to need a longer front brake line. Clubmans normally work with the standard cables.
Where can I see more of this build?
The full photo set for every build is on Instagram at @ironandgasolineofficial, and questions get answered there.
Got a question about this build, or built one yourself? The conversation happens on Instagram — the full photo set for this bike is up there, and I answer everything in the comments.
Join the thread on Instagram
